The new Auction Bay Online storefront!

Welcome to Auction Bay Online, Northwest Indiana’s best online consignment store!

Auction Bay has been in business for over 16 years now, and in that time we’ve accumulated a whopping 40,000+ feedback!

We take pride in each item we list, and will go to great lengths to make sure it sells for as much as the marketplace can fetch for it.  We treat your item like our own, giving it extra attention with professional quality photographs, intense market research, detailed descriptions, and protective packing for when it ships to its new home.

We are located in Historic Downtown Chesterton, IN, right across from Thomas Centennial Park with the gazebo.  We help our customers sell items online, and offer a way to cope with hard economic times.  We can help you clear clutter from your home while simultaneously bringing in much-needed funds.  It’s a win-win situation here at Auction Bay, so don’t hesitate to stop in, enjoy some hot coffee, meet us in person and see how we work!  We go all-out to help you make money on the world-wide marketplace – eBay!

We have a great time selling your stuff!

We have a great time selling your stuff!

Got Questions?  Send an email to or call us at (219) 926-6416

You can also follow our auctions and updates on FacebookClick here to see our page and become a fan!  We’ll be running some Facebook-exclusive promotions for our fans and followers, so don’t wait to give us a look!


Vince - Owner, Proprietor, and all-around cool guy!

Vince – Owner, Proprietor, and all-around cool guy!

Feel free to call at any time and ask for Vince, the owner and operator of this small business, or any of our trained specialists: Jan, Magnolia, Karen, and Amy.


At Auction Bay, we not only pride ourselves on our eBay sales, and how we can help people make money online, but we also have a strong sense of service.  Vince, the owner, is an active member of the Chesterton Lion’s Club and frequently participates in service projects and events like the Sweet Heart Swirl!

Timing is everything!

Be Sociable, Share!